I was relatively good at sports. However, and this is a big however-- my class was comprised of about 26 people. It didn't take much to be "above average" when there were so few people. I wasn't ever picked last, but I don't recall getting picked first much either. Also, when I was captain I always tried to pick people who I thought would be fun to play with rather than those who might ensure victory.

I had an interesting level of too nerdy for the jocks and to "jocky" for the nerds.